Tooth Talk
October 8, 2008
I was having my teeth cleaned by the dental hygienist the other day when she offhandedly asked whether my children were also in the music industry. Fortunately, with my mouth wide open and filled with dental gear, I was only capable of answering with a few rather inarticulate and muffled noises. Otherwise, I might have given her a mouthful of my own. Music industry? How dare she equate what I do with such a mundane term! Am I not an artist? And do I not rub shoulders with the likes of Bach, Mozart, Beethoven, and Schubert, some of the giants of our civilization? Music industry, indeed!
But by the time I walked out of the dentist’s office, my teeth gleaming brilliantly in the morning sunlight, I had changed my mind. Of course I work in the music industry! You could call what I do by other names—profession, career, calling, work, job—but the incontrovertible fact is that I play the violin to feed myself and my family, pay the rent, and occasionally go to the movies. Granted, being a musician is an exalted profession, some might even think of it as a service profession akin to being a doctor or priest, but if I hadn’t been good enough to earn my daily bread from music, I might have only bumped into Mozart and his friends on weekends playing chamber music for fun.
Why did I get so hot under the collar over the hygienist’s innocent question? For one, because music’s noble qualities initially drew me into its world rather than the money I might earn from it. As a child, I eagerly told people that I was going to be a concert violinist when I grew up. “And how would that happen?” the grownups wanted to know. Easy. I would practice hard, develop my God-given talents, and when that glorious day of violin mastery finally arrived, all doors to concerts and acclaim would open enthusiastically and gratefully to me. It hardly crossed my mind to think about the nuts and bolts of the profession—how to practice efficiently, avoid injuries, look for a useful yet affordable instrument, and, not least, to know who the power brokers of the music business were and how to seek them out. Even when I entered the Curtis Institute of Music as an advanced violin student, my naive and romanticized view of the music world lingered on and the school itself did little to dispel these notions. Curtis stuck to doing what a school traditionally does well. It provided me with some of the best teachers in the world who did their job superbly. With each passing year, I improved as a violinist and gradually learned the musician’s craft, but Curtis offered hardly a word about how I might prepare for the outside world after graduation. Only as that date approached did I began to realize that the many fine young fiddlers in my position were all about to set foot in the same highly competitive environment. Ironically, fellow students who showed an innate flare for self-promotion or an awareness of the right people to know met with not-so-subtle criticism. “He’s a real operator,” we would say, or “She knows just exactly who to call and who to kiss up to,” as if making connections to the people in positions of importance was some kind of criminal offence. This prejudice ran contrary to a bald reality: Doors to a successful career might open reluctantly or perhaps not at all to any of us. I tossed and turned many a night in that last year of school thinking of my all-too-uncertain future.
Through talent, a certain amount of luck, and yes, hard work, I have managed to make my way in the music world, but I wish I had been better equipped when my music school diploma was handed to me. Now that I myself teach at the Curtis Institute of Music, I felt comfortable asking Robert Fitzpatrick, the school’s dean, if anything is being done to train young musicians for everything in the profession besides music itself. He referred me to Dan McDougall who gives a course entitled “The Twenty-First-Century Musician” at Curtis. Founded by Phyllis B. Susen, the course strives to build a working knowledge of demands made on musicians, resources available to them, and problem solving. With surprise and just a touch of envy, I learned that last Fall’s course offered fifteen sessions, each given by experts in a chosen subject. These included Basics of Personal Finance; Freelancing: It’s Not So Bad; Life of an Orchestral Musician: As a Player; Audition Taking Tips; The Media, Critics, and You; The Healthy Musician: A Work in Progress; Getting Work—And Making the Most of the Work You Get; and Grant Writing—Show Me The Money. If only this course had been offered to me as a student, my future would have been just as unsure and unpredictable but a tad less scary, armed as I would have been with solid information about the road ahead. I thought of two more course sessions for Professor McDougall to consider for his next syllabus: Performance Jitters–Friend or Foe? and Stage Comportment–Let Us See As Well As Hear the Real You.
I’m due for another teeth cleaning soon. Last time around, I told the hygienist in answer to her question that my daughter Natasha is a singer and my son Alexander is a web designer with many musician clients. But I can’t wait to see the hygienist again: I have so much more to tell her about the music industry.
Subscribe
Sign up to receive new stories straight to your inbox!
Comments
Dear Arnold,
Good to receive your latest writings. I had a similar experience in medical school. No one taught us anything about opening a pracitice in any medical field. We had to figure that out ourselves. How had medicine changed! Now many medical students have MBA’s, and they are thoroughly schooled in the business of medicine. Glad that I went to medical school when I did.
On another subject, Jean and I are coming to your final concert with the Guarnieri in San Francisco on November 20th. Hope that we can see you while you are in town? Understand if you cannot make it.
By the way, Susannah just had a baby girl named Hilde after my mother. First baby! Very exciting.
I hope that you and family are well.
Warmest greetings,
Tom
Dear Arnold,
Good to receive your latest writings. I had a similar experience in medical school. No one taught us anything about opening a pracitice in any medical field. We had to figure that out ourselves. How had medicine changed! Now many medical students have MBA’s, and they are thoroughly schooled in the business of medicine. Glad that I went to medical school when I did.
I hope that you and family are well.
Warmest greetings,
Tom
Hello Arnold,
I greatly enjoy your writings and musings. Part of me is glad that music schools and conservatoria haven’t really jumped on that band wagon of “industry preparation”. Perhaps its because I sort of miss that time of life where there was more space in my head to dream about the music I was playing. I enjoyed the indulgence of dreaming about it in a timeless fashion, accidentally forgetting that this was my bus stop or that I was due at some appointment, and chasing the thoughts and ideas that those dreams inspired to the far reaches of my mind (‘senza’ “get back to work!” calls from the chorus of other voices that seem to lurk there these days!). But yes, how much time has been lost in trying to work out the next step that might have been avoided with a little more knowledge of the “industry.” Incidentally, I was in the dental hygenist’s chair once and the hygenist was excited to have stumbled on a concert on the radio that I happened to be playing in, and proceeded to play it throughout (he was kind anough to ask if it would be ok but how do you object or agree when the only sound you can make is “aaahhh” ?). It certainly is surreal to be at that angle, jaws agape, polishers grinding, a stranger’s eyes looking into your mouth and talking enthusiastically about music. You feel even more vulnerable somehow about that slip of ensemble or intonation than at vertical position…Not recommended!
Dear Arnold Steinhardt,
Thank you for your most recent reflections on the music industry and the usefulness of preparing musicians for it. I don’t know if this was your intention, but I am sure that such words from highly visible and recognized artist will be appreciated all around the world by teachers and administrators struggling to convince students and young musicians to try to get informed and better prepared about the profession. And they may do what I did: tell the younger ensembles we know to read your message.
It was for this reason that at ProQuartet in Paris we started three years ago to collaborate with the Service des informations musicales of the Cité de la musique. They organize workshops all year long to explain the “music industry†to musicians, and we felt that even the excellent groups that had already won major competitions could benefit from their advice. Most of them did, but it is surprising that some still react so negatively to “business talkâ€.
Since we work only with with professional chamber ensembles, the Service conceived special sessions for them, including information for foreigners wanting to understand how the “chamber music industry†works in France (more than half of the 30 or so ensembles we see each year are not French) – which they did in English!
Again thank you for your Fiddler’s Beat,
With best regards,
Evan Rothstein
Leave a Comment
*/