The Interview

December 28, 2012

Giving interviews is something musicians have to do surprisingly often—we usually do them to stir up a little interest and sell a few tickets to our concerts. On one occasion last summer my radio interviewer had done his homework well. He knew a great deal about me, and the music I was going to perform the next evening. Even more gratifying, the
questions he asked were probing and interesting.

That’s not always the case. Interviewers often ask the same lackluster questions over and over—not that I really blame them. After all, their job is to get at the basic facts first and foremost. Where were you born? When did you start playing the violin? Did you hate practicing as a kid? How many hours do you put in daily? When did you decide to become a musician? And so on.

Of course, it’s partially the interviewee’s fault that interviews can be so tedious. Would it be such a sin for musicians to spice up answers a little? Instead of my saying, “I was born in Los Angeles,” how about, “I was born in semi-tropical Los Angeles with fruit trees of all kinds growing in our backyard.” That gives the city and my early life a little more allure, don’t you think? Then there’s this plain-Jane answer I normally give to another basic question: “I started playing the violin when I was six.” Wouldn’t it be better to change that to: “When I was six, my elementary school music teacher, Mr. Singer, knocked on mom and dad’s door and offered me a quarter-size violin, instruction, and a place in the school’s beginners orchestra—all for a two dollar deposit. It was an offer we couldn’t refuse.” See what I mean. It’s an answer rich with meaning and significance. I’m definitely going to use it next time around.

But no matter how much I improve my interview skills, they will always be mediocre in comparison with those of a fellow musician I once met. He had the impressive ability to craft answers that were not only interesting individually but also collectively told a moving and inspirational story.

I met him (name deleted to protect his identity, but let’s call him ‘A’ for
anonymous) at the (name deleted) Music Festival in (country deleted). ‘A’ was a wonderful (instrument deleted)-ist, but unusually quiet in social situations. It was hard to get a word out of ‘A’ which I attributed to a certain reserve or shyness. I asked a friend at the festival about him. To my surprise, he told me that ‘A’ had a completely different and much more flamboyant side to his personality that surfaced now and then.

“For example,” he continued, “’A’ once gave a television interview that is still being talked about. The interviewer began with some typical questions such as: Where were you born? How old were you when you started playing? etc. To this point, ‘A’’s answers were straightforward and unremarkable. But when ‘A’ was asked whether he hated practicing, he told the interviewer that his father had carved from wood a musician figure holding its instrument to keep him company. How could he hate practicing when that enchanting toy musician was always with him? To the question of how many hours a day ‘A’ practiced, he said that he began to practice several hours daily when his father constructed a miniature platform with many carved musician figures on it so that they might inspire him. And as to when ‘A’ finally decided to become a professional musician, he said it was the day that his father presented him as a birthday present with an entire model concert hall he had built complete with stage, tiers of seats, curtains, and audience figures. You can well imagine how the interviewer enthused about ‘A’s life, but especially about his gifted father. The interviewer asked what his father did for a living. “A” said that he was a puppeteer by profession and greatly in demand. He went on to name his father’s
shop and the street address in the oldest part of the city where it was located.

“What a remarkable story,” I exclaimed. My friend looked off in the distance. “You’re not the only one who thought so”, he said. “The television station was deluged with calls as soon as the interview finished. No one working there could remember any interview of the hundreds that had taken place over the years having such a response. Without exception, the viewers who called in were both moved and inspired by ‘A’s story”.

My friend grew silent for a moment and then continued. “About an hour passed and then suddenly, the station was once more deluged with calls from viewers. Only this time it was not in praise of the delightful story they had just heard. It seems that people were so affected by the puppeteer’s fatherly love and whimsical artistry, that they felt impelled to visit his shop and see his work in person.” This part of the story made no sense. “Why call the station? Just visit the puppeteer’s shop,” I blurted out impatiently. My friend regarded me sadly. “You don’t understand, do you? Viewers called the station again because they couldn’t find the name of the puppeteer’s shop or even the name of the street where it was located in the old city.” An odd sort of smile passed over my friend’s face. “’A’s father was not a puppeteer, he had no shop, and the street in the old city didn’t even exist. ‘A’ had made the whole thing up for the interview.”

I sometimes think of ‘A’, especially when I’m about to give an interview. Once or twice, I’ve even been tempted to embellish my answers to the usual questions just to spice things up a little. But then I say to myself, no, there’s only one ‘A’ in the world with a puppeteer father who carves entire concert halls for him. Lucky to have such a father, don’t you think?

Share this Story

Comments

  1. From joan patenaude-yarnell on December 29, 2012

    I always find these stories so charming – so lovely. Yes, I should love to be a subscriber.
    Best wishes to you whole family.

    Joan

  2. From Kyra on December 29, 2012

    Enchanting! I’m captivated, by your tale, your puppeteer, your puppet, and I cannot wait to iterview you!

  3. From Judith Mitrani on December 31, 2012

    Simply charming. Hope to see and to hear you again soon.
    Love,
    Judi & Ted

  4. From Cho-Liang Lin on January 1, 2013

    Another wonderful story, Arnold.
    Top government, corporate and academic leaders often embellish their accomplishments. How many times do we have to answer “So how many hours do you practice a day?” Why not a harmless story about a puppeteer? Good for “A!”
    Happy New Year, Arnold!

    Jimmy

  5. From Nan on January 1, 2013

    Arnold, I love this story. But, come on, who is “A”? Happy New Year – today is Day One.

    Love, Nan

Leave a Comment

Subscribe

Sign up to receive new stories straight to your inbox!

Story Index

Suzy

May 1, 2013

Suzy

Who is more important, the composer or the performer? Or are they like Siamese twins who simply cannot get along without one another?

Thou Shalt Not Steal

April 1, 2013

A Bible Story

Stealing is wrong. You know it. I know it. Or did I?

Arnold Steinhardt

March 4, 2013

Gibbsy

There are a few so-called left-handed violinists. Personally, I have to use both hands to play the violin, but maybe I’m just not talented.

fritz

February 2, 2013

Fritz Kreisler

What happens when four people in a string quartet can’t agree on how to play a musical phrase or even on the merit of an entire work? The great violinist and distinguished composer, Fritz Kreisler, presented the Guarneri String Quartet with just that problem.

The Interview

December 28, 2012

The Interview

Giving interviews is something musicians have to do surprisingly often. But no matter how much I improve my interview skills, they will always be mediocre in comparison with those of a fellow musician I once met.

The Juilliard String Quartet (from left)—Joseph Lin, Joel Krosnick, Samuel Rhodes, and Ronald Copes

November 22, 2012

An Open Letter to Sammy Rhodes

You think quitting smoking is hard? Try quitting a string quartet. My 4-step program might just help Sammy Rhodes quit the Juilliard String Quartet.

cJQuZXoyc5U

September 7, 2012

A Night to Remember

Have you ever heard a concert that you will never forget? And have you ever gone out on a blind date with someone famous to thousands except to you? I have, and both events happened on the same night.

Arnold Giving Colbourn Commencement Speech

May 7, 2012

Colburn School Commencement Address

The first time I gave a commencement address, the school folded one week later. I try again at the 2012 Colburn School graduation ceremony.

The Steinhardt String Quartet, Press Poster

April 1, 2012

The Steinhardt String Quartet

The string quartet has been described as a truly democratic group without leaders or followers—a republic of equals. Think again.

Arnold Steinhardt Sixth Grade Class Photo

March 1, 2012

Teach Me!

Mr. Moldrem, my first violin teacher, easily taught baffling rhythms to his students by comparing them to different fruits. He was a shining example of the teacher’s elusive craft.

Jascha Heifetz

February 2, 2012

Jascha

In Jascha Heifetz, the right body, heart, mind, and guidance came together to produce a violinistic miracle.

The Arnold Steinhardt Metronome

January 5, 2012

You’re On Your Own

I have very mixed feelings about the metronome, mainly because it’s so….metronomic. But let me explain.

Meryl Streep as Roberta Guaspari

December 4, 2011

Uh-Oh

Musicians are often compared to actors, but if you’re good as one, should you necessarily be good as the other?

Rock Concert T-shirt

November 1, 2011

Listen

I go to my first rock concert ever with ear plugs in my ears and discover up close why the world’s ears are at risk.

Manuscript of Beethoven's Grosse Fuge

October 3, 2011

Opus 130

How often does a work of music change your life? Ludwig van Beethoven’s String Quartet, Opus 130, changed mine but it took me several years to realize it.

Arnold Steinhardt's Violin Case

September 9, 2011

My Violin Case

It’s just for a violin and bow, right? Wrong.

Rudolf Serkin, pianist, and Arnold Steinhardt, violinist, 1980

August 2, 2011

Marlboro at Sixty

The Marlboro Music School celebrated its sixtieth anniversary last summer. For many of us, it was the most important musical experience of our lives.

Stage F-F-Fright

July 1, 2011

Stage F-F-Fright

An age-old problem has a host of possible solutions including specific practice, meditation, and an unlikely drug.

Del Gesu Beare, Scrolls

June 6, 2011

An Old Friend

The violin I play is my partner and my friend. Such a violin that I’ve not seen in thirty years returns for us to get reacquainted.

Practice, Practice

May 3, 2011

Practice, Practice

Practice makes perfect whether in ballet, tennis, chess, or music. But hours of mindless practice may lead you astray. Enter the master teacher as guide.

The Duo

April 1, 2011

The Duo

An exciting and unusual new chamber music endeavor. Now booking!

A-Meditation-on-the-Meditation_Featured-Image

March 1, 2011

A Meditation on the Meditation

An alluring violin solo in an opera by Jules Massenet acquires a life of its own as a violinistic showcase. Beloved by some, belittled by others, the Meditation has nevertheless remained in the repertoire for over a hundred years.

Forty Year Story

February 3, 2011

Forty Year Story

I was young and inexperienced but I managed to do right by my students. The consequences might surprise you.

Perfect Pitch Tablets from Tone Deaf Comics

January 3, 2011

Perfect What?

So your little genius has perfect pitch. Big deal.

David Soyer

December 6, 2010

Dave

When someone I know dies, I find myself taking inventory almost without realizing it. In David Soyer’s case, I will remember him as a marvelous cellist, an uncommon musician, and as an extraordinary human being.

Paganini's Birthday

October 27, 2010

Paganini’s Birthday

I pay tribute to the great violinist with words, music, and a letter sent to him at his grave in Parma, Italy.

Photo from Opus

October 4, 2010

Opus

Michael Hollander’s play about string quartets explores both this great medium’s pitfalls and its bliss.

Hermes/Mercury, God of Travel

September 6, 2010

Psssst

Open your hearts and minds to the great adventure of getting from point A to point B on firm ground or at 35,000 feet, on time or maddeningly late.

In a Sentimental Mood

August 2, 2010

In a Sentimental Mood

“Sentimental” according to one definition, means having sentiment or feeling but that quality seems to have fallen on hard times. Why are we so uncomfortable with a heart that beats unashamedly on the sleeve?

Dinner Music

July 1, 2010

Dinner Music

A string quartet competes badly with hot dogs, mustard, and relish.

Disney Hall

June 2, 2010

Something New, Something Old

We’re tired of hearing the same old works over and over again, yet unhappy if not downright uncomprehending listening to the very new. Something’s got to give.

Joe Vita

May 4, 2010

Joe Vita

A passion for music appears in an unlikely person and place.

Twelve Note Story

April 23, 2010

Twelve Note Story

Take a deep breath and try to settle down. I know, I know. The task is daunting, but you’ve worked hard. Just be relaxed. Be focused. And now get practical. …

News Alert

March 30, 2010

News Alert

The United States Bureau of Weights and Measures has just announced at a national news conference that chamber music may cause global warming. Read on.

Sophisticated Traveler

February 28, 2010

Sophisticated Traveler

It happened to me. I sure hope it doesn’t happen to you. But it could.

Grammy Award

January 18, 2010

Grammy Awards

It will be an honor just to have been nominated for such a prestigious award, won’t it? Won’t it???

Shall We Dance?

January 4, 2010

Shall We Dance?

I play Bach for an elderly musician who responds by dancing for me and opening up a new world of understanding.

Looking for Work

December 1, 2009

Looking for Work

The Guarneri String Quartet retired, but a guy’s got to do something with the rest of his life.

Birth Pains

November 4, 2009

Birth Pains

Mozart’s String Quartet, K. 421 in D Minor was the very first music the Guarneri String Quartet read through after deciding to form as a group. I can think of two other birth events associated with this emotive work.

The Guarneri Quartet

October 6, 2009

For the Very Last Time

The Guarneri String Quartet says goodbye after forty-five years on the concert stage.

Gray's Papaya

September 1, 2009

Gray’s Papaya

Where a hot dog on a bun with mustard and sauerkraut is undisputed king.

Second Concert

August 3, 2009

Second Concert

Musicians usually perform for the well-heeled members of society but I unexpectedly play for an audience of homeless people — with moving results.

Arthur Rubinstein

July 7, 2009

Really

“I just loved your playing”, he said at the end of the concert. But did he mean it?

Life, Death, Music

June 13, 2009

Life, Death, Music

A teenager I’ve never met before sets in motion a story of life, death, and the enormous power of music.

Almost on the Riviera

May 11, 2009

Almost on the Riviera

I audition for a movie role as a violinist. So close to stardom, yet so far.

The Abode

April 1, 2009

The Abode

Where do chamber music players go when they retire from concertizing? Here’s your answer.

Yehudi Menuhin

March 5, 2009

Genie in a Bottle

I record, therefore I am at your service at any hour of the day, every day of the year, for eternity.

A Brush with Fame

February 8, 2009

The Brush With Fame

For mere seconds, a crooner, an actress, and a violin student come together in unlikely fashion.

New Years Thoughts

January 1, 2009

New Year’s Thoughts

Some comments from the Guarneri String Quartet’s listeners on the eve of its retirement.

The Swan

December 1, 2008

The Swan

One of the most alluring melodies ever written for the cello. So sweet, so simple. Well, not exactly.

Mr. Oliver

November 10, 2008

Mr. Oliver

A music teacher in danger of losing his job prompts his class to write a letter of support with unimagined short- and long-term consequences.

Tooth Talk

October 8, 2008

Tooth Talk

It’s not food, it’s not a roof over your head, and it’s not procreation. So what exactly is music good for?

What Good is Music

September 11, 2008

What Good is Music?

It’s not food, it’s not a roof over your head, and it’s not procreation. So what exactly is music good for?

A Tale of Three Violinists

August 10, 2008

A Tale of Three Violinists

When one young, one old, and one truly terrible violinist meet, ignorance, greatness, and comedy reign all at once.

Last Words to a Son

July 11, 2008

Last Words to a Son

My mother gives me a compliment just before leaving this earth at 101 years of age.

A Dog's Tale

June 12, 2008

A Dog’s Tale

I’m such a wonderful teacher. You don’t believe me, do you? Let me show you why.

Remembering Izzy

May 10, 2008

Remembering Izzy

Isidore Cohen, a distinguished violinist, is remembered and honored in a most unusual way years after his passing.

A Noteworthy Day

March 2, 2008

A Noteworthy Day

Sounds. They’re everywhere. Who is responsible for them? And I’m not talking about music.

Solo Bow

February 2, 2008

Solo Bow

Perhaps I shouldn’t have read those program notes about Beethoven’s String Quartet Opus 18 #5 before we, the Guarneri Quartet, walked out onto the stage to perform it.

In the Key of Strawberry

January 1, 2008

In the Key of Strawberry

The Talmud says that a dream not understood is like a letter unopened. A search for the meaning of my strange dream comes up with surprising results.

Hiroshi Iizuka

December 1, 2007

Cousin Sam

There are large foundations and small foundations. Then there is my cousin Sam whose generosity proved contagious.